KAMPALA, Uganda — A recent landmark ruling by Uganda’s Court of Appeal offers an inside look into the legal process that effectively dismissed tycoon Mohan Musisi Kiwanuka from control of his vast, multi-million dollar estate. The judgment, which definitively declared Kiwanuka mentally incapacitated due to Alzheimer’s disease since at least May 18, 2017, not only concluded a protracted family dispute but also exposed critical procedural flaws in an earlier High Court decision.
The unanimous verdict, delivered by Justices Cheborion Barishaki, Christopher Gashirabake, and Dr. Asa Mugenyi, was rooted in what they termed “damning evidence.” This included consistent testimonies from four of Kiwanuka’s own sisters and two of his medical doctors, who collectively painted a stark picture of cognitive decline. Their accounts detailed significant memory loss, profound personality changes, and a noticeable inability to perform basic daily tasks independently – a pattern the court found impossible to ignore.
This appellate decision meticulously dismantled and overturned a 2019 High Court ruling by Justice Musa Sekaana, which had surprisingly dismissed an application by Jordan Ssebuliba Kiwanuka, the tycoon’s son, to subject his father to a formal mental health evaluation. The Court of Appeal did not merely reverse the earlier judgment; it launched a scathing critique of the High Court’s methods.
Central to this criticism was a highly irregular and unrecorded 15-minute private session between the High Court judge and Kiwanuka at the Golden Tulip Hotel. The appellate justices condemned this secret meeting, stating, “This defect taints the inquiry, and the entire trial, with mystery and suspicion.” Their analysis suggested that this procedural lapse undermined the integrity of the initial inquiry into Kiwanuka’s mental state.
While earlier narratives suggested the son’s legal action was driven by avarice for his father’s considerable wealth, the Court of Appeal’s analytical judgment dismissed these claims. The court found that the evidence supported the argument that the application stemmed from a genuine concern for the patriarch’s well-being. The judgment acknowledged, “It is not unexpected for a son who has worked closely with his father for over 20 years and noticed memory loss to worry,” thereby reframing the core motivation of the legal challenge.
The practical consequence of this exhaustive legal review is the formal removal of Mohan Kiwanuka’s capacity to manage his extensive business affairs. The court’s directive now mandates that all his lineal descendants and wives be granted full access to him. More significantly for the future of his empire, the judgment orders the convening of a family meeting within 30 days to appoint a new manager for his expansive estate. This effectively transfers the stewardship of a portfolio that court documents confirm includes 46 prime properties across Kampala, with at least 26 located in the upscale Kololo neighborhood, and a contentious 50-acre parcel in Sonde, Mukono District.
The ruling sets a precedent, emphasizing the judiciary’s role in safeguarding the interests of individuals suffering from cognitive impairments, even when their estates are vast and family disputes are complex.
