Friday, May 23, 2025
UG Standard - Latest News
  • Home
  • News
    • DIPLOMACY
    • COURT
    • AFRICA
    • BOOK REVIEW
    • INTERVIEW:
    • National
    • Parliament
    • World
    • Regional
  • Business
    • AGRIBUSINESS
    • OIL & GAS
    • REAL ESTATE
    • TECH
    • INNOVATIONS
    • TELCOM
  • OpED
  • EDUCATION
  • INVESTIGATION
    • NATIONAL ARCHIVE
    • SPECIAL REPORT
    • ANALYSIS
  • FEATURES
    • SOCIETY
    • Community
    • Pictorial
    • PROFILES
    • Lifestyle
    • Health
    • ENVIRONMENT
  • Tours & Travel
    • Hotel & Hospitality
  • Sports
  • About Us
  • Login
UG Standard - Latest News
Your browser does not support the video tag.
ADVERTISEMENT

BLATANT FLAWS! Molly Katanga’s case exposes ODPP, criminal justice system in Uganda

by MANFRED TUMUSIIME | UG STANDARD REPORTER
03/07/2024
in News
Reading Time: 5 mins read
A A
0
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
Ms Katanga at court on Tuesday. The prosecutors continue to insist bringing her to court, despite the state of her physical condition

KAMPALA – Is Molly Katanga a survivor of severe domestic violence? It is a question that pervades constant discussion in the wake of the pull and shove between the unfortunate widow and the state apparatus, a matter that has reawakened concerns about Uganda’s criminal justice system.

Despite evidence adduced by her strong defence team of lawyers, which is constituted with two former head prosecutors – the highly respected Peter Kabatsi and the highly technical MacDosman Kabega, who have cited so many procedural flaws that disadvantage her defence, the office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (ODPP) has continued to wantonly disregard the concerns, some which border on human rights violations.

Related posts

Ugandan human rights advocate Agather Atuhaire speaks passionately on civic space in Kampala.

Uganda gov’t writes to Tanzania over detained rights firebrand Agather Atuhaire

22/05/2025
169
D/ASP Charles Twine (in army green jacket) with Noah Mutwe arriving at Buganda Road court on Thursday. (Courtesy photo)

Former CID spokesperson Twine charged for ridiculing President Museveni and Gen Muhoozi

22/05/2025
160
Uganda faces a staggering 3 trillion shilling fiscal loss annually as illicit alcohol consumption, driven by extreme affordability, accounts for 40% of the total market value.

Uganda Faces Billions in Tax Losses from Thriving Illicit Alcohol Trade

22/05/2025
165
Uganda's export earnings soared 40% in March 2025 to $899M, primarily driven by strong performances in coffee, gold, and fish, reflecting rising global prices and increased volumes.

Coffee, Gold Drive Uganda’s March Exports to Sh3.3 Trillion

22/05/2025
152

Firstly, Ms Katanga was repeatedly denied bail, inspite of overwhelming evidence that she had survived the unfortunate incident on November 2, 2023 but left in a vegetative state and despite government doctors from the Ministry of Health, appointed by the ODPP confirming that she needed specialised treatment outside the Luzira Prison walls.

Katanga’s devastating injuries and subsequent denial of bail, despite facing serious charges of murder, raise questions about the system’s ability to hold perpetrators accountable and protect victims’ rights.

Advocates argue that the system often fails to address serious human rights issues.

According to city lawyer and human rights advocate Isaac Ssemakadde, it is now settled law that denying bail solely based on arbitrary and capricious factors such as the accused person’s age, or a medical condition that could be treated in prison, or a no-objection chit by the DPP, is an unjustified restriction on liberty, violating Article 23(6)(a) of the Ugandan Constitution (right to bail) and Article 28(3)(a) (presumption of innocence).

“It also violates international human rights law, particularly Article 9(3) of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, which provides that “It shall not be the general rule that persons awaiting trial shall be detained in custody…” he noted.

Mr. Ssemakadde argued that in Molly Katanga’s case, the High court judge blatantly committed two other cardinal errors — firstly, by fetishising the July 2, 2024 hearing date for Molly Katanga’s main case, “Judge Muwata disregarded a pertinent decision of the Constitutional court in Hon Sam Kuteesa & 2 others v Attorney General, Reference No 54 of 2011,” Mr. Ssemakadde wrote.

The systemic flaws leading to Ms Katanga’s unjust treatment are entrenched, requiring a comprehensive overhaul of the criminal justice system, some analyts have pointed out.

“The government, judiciary, and law enforcement agencies must acknowledge the failures and work towards creating a justice system that prioritizes victims’ protection and empowerment,” an advocate who requested to speak off the record to foster a free discussion says.

For example, the right to bail is enshrined under the 1995 Constitution of Uganda. It is a procedure by which a judge or magistrate sets at liberty one who has been arrested or imprisoned upon receipt of security to ensure the released prisoner’s later appearance in court for further proceedings.

The purpose of bail pending trial in criminal cases is to avoid inflicting punishment upon an innocent person (who may later be acquitted at trial) and to encourage the unhampered preparation of their defence.

In Uganda today, analysts argue, that the ODPP has misconstrued bail as a way to punish offenders who have not been formally found guilty and has repeatedly denied bail as a form of punishment to accused persons that the office deem guilty until proven innocent.

“There have been arguments that denying bail prevents provoking and inflaming public sensitivities,” one analyst noted.

This is the argument that has been made time and again in the case of Molly Katanga – as if public sensitivities trump the constitutional presumption of innocence until proven guilty, her defence team has consistently complained.

Despite being in a vegetative state, prosecutors from the Office of Director of Public Prosecutions insisted she should be denied bail despite government doctors from the Ministry of Health confirming her medical condition was grave and needed specialised attention outside Luzira Prison

What has been missed in all of this, is the very real fact that the concept of bail is a critical aspect of the rule of law and is an example of how our legal system reflects principles the presumption of innocence.
The primary principles that underpin bail legislation in Uganda include the Presumption of Innocence and the Right to Liberty, and these are part of the larger framework of the rule of law.

The bail process must uphold these principles to ensure we maintain a fair and just legal system. The law is not about vengeance, rage, or prejudice.

For example, in Ms Katanga’s case, the judge’s decision to repeatedly deny bail disregarded Constitutional Court precedents perpetuated prison congestion, morbidity, mortality and case backlog.

Such has been the gravity of the issues, that a lawsuit filed at the East African Court of Justice by some members of the Ugandan public seeks to address these issues, alleging a breach of good governance principles and seeking a declaration that police, prosecutors, and judicial officers must demonstrate compelling reasons to deny bail.

This case is not just about Ms Katanga but about ensuring good governance and protecting citizens’ rights, its proponents say.

“The Ugandan government must prioritize reforming its criminal justice system to uphold justice, equality, and human rights,” one of the advocates says.
Ms Katanga’s case has also revived the longstanding debate in the Ugandan public about Gender-based violence.

The problem is pervasive in Uganda, with 56% of married women experiencing physical and sexual violence from their husbands, according to statistics from the Ministry of Gender.
“The criminal justice system’s failure to address this issue perpetuates the cycle of violence, leaving victims without protection or recourse,” says one of the campaigners.

In the ongoing case, the ODPP and police have been accused of failure to investigate Ms Katanga’s injuries, instead accusing her of killing her husband, despite the postmortem report suggesting she was attached.
Analysts have criticised both the police and ODPP, arguing that this demonstrates a lack of gender-sensitive approach.

Other issues that Ms Katanga’s case have exposed especially about the office of the ODPP incude the slow pace of justice, reliance on circumstantial evidence, and lack of access to legal representation and medical care — all significant flaws that must be addressed through comprehensive reform.

Proponents critical of the ODPP for lack of procedural fairness in Ms Katanga’s case, cite an example of the late Bob Kasango, reportedly tragically died in Luzira Prison two weeks after he was ‘maliciously’ denied bail.

Following his demise, Luzira prison confirmed that he had been ill and, in fact, died en route to Mulago Hospital.
He had been denied proper medical care in spite of the fact that medical reports had deemed his life in urgent need of specialist medical attention.

In his eulogy Andrew Mwenda said “Bob didn’t have to die at this early age and in the way he did – alone and lonely, away from the care of his family and friends or competent doctors, in a prison hospital not equipped to handle his condition”.
The judiciary issued a statement at the time denying any responsibility for Kasango’s death. They argued that the only thing they did was to simply deny him bail!

Analysts cite these precedents and hence argue that the criminal justice system should not be engineered to undercut established principles of fairness and justice.

“It must not be employed to exact revenge at the behest of invisible puppet masters pulling the DPP’s strings,” and advocate, unhappy with the conduct of the ODPP in Ms Katanga’s case argued.
He wondered why the wheels of justice move so slowly in the Ugandan judicial system that accused persons remain imprisoned for as many as seven years before they are heard.

Citing an example of NUP activist Olivia Lutaaya and her co accused who were charged for making petroleum bombs and have been on remand for three years at the behest of a military tribunal.
“The state has not adduced any shred of evidence against her, and yet she can not be granted bail. The state, in essence, has enough evidence to keep her imprisoned for three years but not enough to commence her trial,” the advocate said, adding that Ms Lutaaya is a textbook example of why the right to bail exists.
“Should a trial eventually take place and acquit her – how would she be compensated for the loss of liberty for three years? Why is the ODPP so cavalier about human rights? Do they not know the old adage that “injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere?” he asked.

As Ms Katanga and her co-accused take their turn in court, it is important that the process weaknesses in the criminal justice system in Uganda are identified, discussed and addressed to foster a fair process for all.

Share this:

  • Share
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Click to share on Telegram (Opens in new window) Telegram
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

Tags: BLATANT FLAWS! Molly Katanga's case exposes ODPPcriminal justice system in UgandaFeaturedMolly KatangaUganda

Related Posts

 Abbas urges U.S. to compel Israel to stop violations against Palestinians
News

 Abbas urges U.S. to compel Israel to stop violations against Palestinians

05/11/2022
0
236

Abbas urges U.S. to compel Israel to stop violations against Palestinians RAMALLAH, Nov. 4 (Xinhua) -- Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas...

Read moreDetails
Equity ranked 4th strongest banking brand globally on brand strength, scoring 92.4 points out of 100

 Equity Bank Under Scrutiny for Alleged Role in UGX.3bn Fake Gold Scam

09/07/2024
531
Kabuleta and other opposition politicians have teamed up to put an end to Museveni's leadership

 Kabuleta, other opposition politicians team up to put an end to Museveni’s leadership

27/02/2024
392
President Museveni

 Museveni commends Ugandan scientists! 

21/07/2020
854
Load More

Popular Articles

  • Check out the top schools with pupils who scored 6 in 4 aggregates in the 2024 PLE results, as released by UNEB

    PLE 2024 Results: Top Schools with 6 in 4 Aggregates

    4300 shares
    Share 1720 Tweet 1075
  • NIRA unveils high-tech National ID, mass enrollment set to begin

    2586 shares
    Share 1034 Tweet 647
  • FULL LIST: Ministry of Education, NCDC publish self-study workbooks amid COVID-19 lockdown

    3318 shares
    Share 1346 Tweet 822
  • How to Check PLE Results 2024 on Phone, Online

    1776 shares
    Share 710 Tweet 444
  • PLE 2024 Results: UNEB Clarifies on Release Date

    1646 shares
    Share 658 Tweet 412
  • MPs clear govt to cancel 2020 academic year

    2795 shares
    Share 1149 Tweet 686
  • UNEB agrees to adjust examinations timetables to accommodate lost time

    2660 shares
    Share 1086 Tweet 656

Recent Articles

Ugandan human rights advocate Agather Atuhaire speaks passionately on civic space in Kampala.

Uganda gov’t writes to Tanzania over detained rights firebrand Agather Atuhaire

22/05/2025
MediPay, a new InsurTech solution from the 2025 COMESA Women in FinTech Hackathon, empowers rural women in Zambia & Malawi with digital tools for affordable healthcare access, loans, & insurance

MediPay Targets Healthcare Access for Rural Women in Zambia, Malawi

22/05/2025
D/ASP Charles Twine (in army green jacket) with Noah Mutwe arriving at Buganda Road court on Thursday. (Courtesy photo)

Former CID spokesperson Twine charged for ridiculing President Museveni and Gen Muhoozi

22/05/2025
Uganda faces a staggering 3 trillion shilling fiscal loss annually as illicit alcohol consumption, driven by extreme affordability, accounts for 40% of the total market value.

Uganda Faces Billions in Tax Losses from Thriving Illicit Alcohol Trade

22/05/2025

IBA concludes global ESG training program for lawyers

22/05/2025
Phillip Kihumuro the Forest Restorations Project Manager WWF Uganda.

WWF Uganda advocates for local-led conservation

22/05/2025
Uganda's export earnings soared 40% in March 2025 to $899M, primarily driven by strong performances in coffee, gold, and fish, reflecting rising global prices and increased volumes.

Coffee, Gold Drive Uganda’s March Exports to Sh3.3 Trillion

22/05/2025

Recent CommentsRecent Comments

  • BIG STORY: US FDA Accepts Dei BioPharma’s Application For Ground Breaking Biological Diabetes And Weight Loss Drug – Press Uganda on BIG STORY: US FDA accepts Dei BioPharma’s application for ground breaking biological diabetes and weight loss drug
  • Week 6: 30 More Take Home Prizes In Shell Uganda Driver Promo – Press Uganda on Week 6: 30 More Take Home Prizes in Shell Uganda Driver Promo
  • Advocate Charged And Remanded Over Forgery – Press Uganda on Advocate charged and remanded over Forgery
  • Stanbic Bank Uganda Offers Preapproved Mortgages Up To 500M – Press Uganda on Stanbic Bank Uganda Offers Preapproved Mortgages Up to 500M
  • BroadPay Building Bridges To Financial Inclusion Through Local Payment Innovation – Press Uganda on BroadPay Building Bridges to Financial Inclusion Through Local Payment Innovation
UG Standard - Latest News

UG Standard, published via www.ugstandard.com isa publication of Sahel Media Solutions Ltd, a professional Digital/New Media company in Uganda info@ugstandard.com

Follow us on social media:

Latest News

  • Uganda gov’t writes to Tanzania over detained rights firebrand Agather Atuhaire
  • MediPay Targets Healthcare Access for Rural Women in Zambia, Malawi
  • Former CID spokesperson Twine charged for ridiculing President Museveni and Gen Muhoozi
  • Uganda Faces Billions in Tax Losses from Thriving Illicit Alcohol Trade
  • IBA concludes global ESG training program for lawyers
  • WWF Uganda advocates for local-led conservation

OpED

Understanding Air Expansion and Its Impact in Kasese District, Western Uganda

The Empire, the Spectacle, and the Soft Coup in South Africa

Inside South Africa’s Retail Shake-Up

Afrikaners for the U.S. as Refugees?

In Memoriam: Rajiv Ruparelia – A Legacy of Vision and Heart

© 2024 Ugstandard - Latest News by Digital/New Media company.

Welcome Back!

Sign In with Facebook
OR

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • DIPLOMACY
    • COURT
    • AFRICA
    • BOOK REVIEW
    • INTERVIEW:
    • National
    • Parliament
    • World
    • Regional
  • Business
    • AGRIBUSINESS
    • OIL & GAS
    • REAL ESTATE
    • TECH
    • INNOVATIONS
    • TELCOM
  • OpED
  • EDUCATION
  • INVESTIGATION
    • NATIONAL ARCHIVE
    • SPECIAL REPORT
    • ANALYSIS
  • FEATURES
    • SOCIETY
    • Community
    • Pictorial
    • PROFILES
    • Lifestyle
    • Health
    • ENVIRONMENT
  • Tours & Travel
    • Hotel & Hospitality
  • Sports
  • About Us

© 2024 Ugstandard - Latest News by Digital/New Media company.

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
%d