Friday, May 23, 2025
UG Standard - Latest News
  • Home
  • News
    • DIPLOMACY
    • COURT
    • AFRICA
    • BOOK REVIEW
    • INTERVIEW:
    • National
    • Parliament
    • World
    • Regional
  • Business
    • AGRIBUSINESS
    • OIL & GAS
    • REAL ESTATE
    • TECH
    • INNOVATIONS
    • TELCOM
  • OpED
  • EDUCATION
  • INVESTIGATION
    • NATIONAL ARCHIVE
    • SPECIAL REPORT
    • ANALYSIS
  • FEATURES
    • SOCIETY
    • Community
    • Pictorial
    • PROFILES
    • Lifestyle
    • Health
    • ENVIRONMENT
  • Tours & Travel
    • Hotel & Hospitality
  • Sports
  • About Us
  • Login
UG Standard - Latest News
Your browser does not support the video tag.
ADVERTISEMENT

Supreme Court of Uganda Upholds Significance of Plea Taking and Right to Fair Hearing in Landmark Ruling

by WINNIE NAKAMATTE | REPORTER
21/04/2024
in News
Reading Time: 2 mins read
A A
0
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
Supreme Court of Uganda Upholds Significance of Plea Taking and Right to Fair Hearing in Landmark Ruling

In a landmark decision handed down by the Supreme Court of Uganda on January 17, 2024, the case of Uganda v Hajji Elisa Namunyu & 5 Ors (Criminal Appeal No. 49 of 2020) has shed light on two fundamental aspects of criminal proceedings: the significance of plea taking and the right to a fair hearing.

“The significance of plea taking cannot be overstated. It is the foundation upon which the accused person gets to know the details of the case against them and prepares their defense,” said Justice Ruby Opio Aweri, speaking for the court.

Related posts

The accused person (standing) in court on Tuesday as they read for him the charges. Courtesy photo

Former Lira district Councilor remanded over charges of Conspiracy to defraud

20/05/2025
167
Amb. Milton Kambula, President Global Peace Foundation (GPF)

2026 Elections: Amb. Kambula urges Ugandans to Desistfrom Political, Tribal Divisions

20/05/2025
165
Deputy Chief Justice Dr. Flavian Zeija being welcomed by Acting Chief Registrar, Pamella Lamunu and Judiciary Public Relations Officer, Eremye Mawanda on Thursday.

Judiciary extends service closer to people on Buvuma Court open day

18/05/2025
167
The acused in dock on Friday. (Courtesy photo)

Advocate charged and remanded over Forgery

17/05/2025
270

The Supreme Court emphasized that plea taking is essential in criminal trials, as it forms the basis upon which the accused person gets to know the details of the case against them and prepares their defense. The court noted that the respondents had actively participated in the trial, raising a defense of alibi, cross-examining prosecution witnesses, and providing evidence as defense witnesses, despite the lack of a specific recording of their plea.

“The respondents’ active participation in the trial demonstrates that they had understood the charges against them and prepared their defense. Substantive justice requires that anomalies in the plea-taking process be overlooked in favor of the broader cause of justice,” said Justice Aweri.

The court also reaffirmed the fundamental right to a fair hearing, emphasizing that courts must uphold this right even in the face of procedural errors to prevent miscarriages of justice. “The failure of the Court of Appeal to accord the parties the right to address the court on an issue not raised in the memorandum of appeal was a misdirection and erroneous in law. It violated the parties’ right to a fair hearing and occasioned a miscarriage of justice,” said Justice Aweri.

The background of the case is as follows: On April 27, 2015, the respondents faced trial at the High Court in Mbale, Uganda, where they were convicted of murder under sections 188 and 189 of the Penal Code Act. Dissatisfied with the verdict, the respondents appealed both their conviction and sentence. The Court of Appeal, sitting at Masaka, discovered a critical procedural flaw: the respondents had not entered a plea during the initial trial. Consequently, the Court of Appeal quashed the proceedings and set aside the sentences. Rather than ordering a retrial, it opted for a stay of prosecution, leading to the immediate release of the respondents.

The Supreme Court’s findings were as follows:

– “The failure of the Court of Appeal to accord the parties the right to address the court on an issue not raised in the memorandum of appeal was a misdirection and erroneous in law.”
– “The Court of Appeal’s decision violated the parties’ right to a fair hearing and occasioned a miscarriage of justice.”
– “The respondents’ active participation in the trial, despite the lack of a specific recording of their plea, demonstrated that they had understood the charges against them and prepared their defense.”
– “Substantive justice requires that anomalies in the plea-taking process be overlooked in favor of the broader cause of justice.”

The Supreme Court’s decision serves as a reminder that human rights, including the right to a fair trial, are inherent and must not be compromised by procedural technicalities. “Courts should prioritize substantive justice and ensure accused individuals have a fair opportunity to defend themselves, maintaining the integrity of the judicial process,” said Justice Aweri.

Share this:

  • Share
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Click to share on Telegram (Opens in new window) Telegram
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

Tags: FeaturedPlea takingSupreme Court of Uganda

Related Posts

 Abbas urges U.S. to compel Israel to stop violations against Palestinians
News

 Abbas urges U.S. to compel Israel to stop violations against Palestinians

05/11/2022
0
236

Abbas urges U.S. to compel Israel to stop violations against Palestinians RAMALLAH, Nov. 4 (Xinhua) -- Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas...

Read moreDetails
Equity ranked 4th strongest banking brand globally on brand strength, scoring 92.4 points out of 100

 Equity Bank Under Scrutiny for Alleged Role in UGX.3bn Fake Gold Scam

09/07/2024
533
Kabuleta and other opposition politicians have teamed up to put an end to Museveni's leadership

 Kabuleta, other opposition politicians team up to put an end to Museveni’s leadership

27/02/2024
394
President Museveni

 Museveni commends Ugandan scientists! 

21/07/2020
855
Load More

Popular Articles

  • Check out the top schools with pupils who scored 6 in 4 aggregates in the 2024 PLE results, as released by UNEB

    PLE 2024 Results: Top Schools with 6 in 4 Aggregates

    4301 shares
    Share 1720 Tweet 1075
  • NIRA unveils high-tech National ID, mass enrollment set to begin

    2590 shares
    Share 1036 Tweet 648
  • FULL LIST: Ministry of Education, NCDC publish self-study workbooks amid COVID-19 lockdown

    3318 shares
    Share 1346 Tweet 822
  • How to Check PLE Results 2024 on Phone, Online

    1776 shares
    Share 710 Tweet 444
  • PLE 2024 Results: UNEB Clarifies on Release Date

    1647 shares
    Share 659 Tweet 412
  • MPs clear govt to cancel 2020 academic year

    2795 shares
    Share 1149 Tweet 686
  • UNEB agrees to adjust examinations timetables to accommodate lost time

    2660 shares
    Share 1086 Tweet 656

Recent Articles

Uganda's Constitutional Court delivers landmark ruling, denying Leadership Code Tribunal members judicial privileges

HRNJ-Uganda Supported Journalist Wins 5-Year Legal Battle Against Brutal Ex-Lira Mayor

23/05/2025
D/ASP Charles Twine (in army green jacket) with Noah Mutwe arriving at Buganda Road court on Thursday.

TREASON? Ex-CID Boss Busted for Threatening Museveni, Muhoozi!

23/05/2025
Gen. Salim Saleh, a key presidential advisor, meets with European Union officials, including Ambassador Jan Sadek in Gulu, Uganda, calling for a "political ceasefire" and inter-party dialogue ahead of the 2026 general election.

Gen. Saleh addresses EU concerns over CDF Muhoozi’s tweets

23/05/2025
Uganda's Education Ministry has issued strict new guidelines banning extravagant school parties, luxury transport, and lavish election campaigns. The move aims to restore discipline and curb excessive displays of wealth, with headteachers facing disciplinary action for non-compliance.

Education ministry bans cars, couples, choppers and lavish parties in schools

23/05/2025

aBi Finance, UIBFS Equip Lenders for Climate Challenges

23/05/2025
Tree-climbing lions in Ishasha, are one of the wildlife attractions unique to Uganda and a few other countries on the African continent. With proper investment in marketing the destination

UK travel advisories hurt Uganda park tourism

23/05/2025

Whistleblower Alleges Widespread Judicial Fraud in Uganda Courts

23/05/2025

Recent CommentsRecent Comments

  • Parliamentary Committee Grills Local Government Over PDM Funds, Accountability – Press Uganda on Parliamentary committee grills local government over PDM funds, accountability
  • Uganda Faces Billions In Tax Losses From Thriving Illicit Alcohol Trade – Press Uganda on Uganda Faces Billions in Tax Losses from Thriving Illicit Alcohol Trade
  • CAUGHT RED-HANDED?! Top Kampala Lawyer-Lender Faces Claims Of Courtroom Manipulation And “Phantom Documents”! – Press Uganda on CAUGHT RED-HANDED?! Top Kampala Lawyer-Lender Faces Claims of Courtroom Manipulation and “Phantom Documents”!
  • Centenary Bank Boss: Startups Should Leverage TikTok For Growth – Press Uganda on Centenary Bank boss: Startups Should Leverage TikTok for Growth
  • 3 Dead, 9 Injured In Mukono Highway Crash – Press Uganda on 3 Dead, 9 Injured in Mukono Highway Crash
UG Standard - Latest News

UG Standard, published via www.ugstandard.com isa publication of Sahel Media Solutions Ltd, a professional Digital/New Media company in Uganda info@ugstandard.com

Follow us on social media:

Latest News

  • HRNJ-Uganda Supported Journalist Wins 5-Year Legal Battle Against Brutal Ex-Lira Mayor
  • TREASON? Ex-CID Boss Busted for Threatening Museveni, Muhoozi!
  • Gen. Saleh addresses EU concerns over CDF Muhoozi’s tweets
  • Education ministry bans cars, couples, choppers and lavish parties in schools
  • aBi Finance, UIBFS Equip Lenders for Climate Challenges
  • UK travel advisories hurt Uganda park tourism

OpED

Understanding Air Expansion and Its Impact in Kasese District, Western Uganda

The Empire, the Spectacle, and the Soft Coup in South Africa

Inside South Africa’s Retail Shake-Up

Afrikaners for the U.S. as Refugees?

In Memoriam: Rajiv Ruparelia – A Legacy of Vision and Heart

© 2024 Ugstandard - Latest News by Digital/New Media company.

Welcome Back!

Sign In with Facebook
OR

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • DIPLOMACY
    • COURT
    • AFRICA
    • BOOK REVIEW
    • INTERVIEW:
    • National
    • Parliament
    • World
    • Regional
  • Business
    • AGRIBUSINESS
    • OIL & GAS
    • REAL ESTATE
    • TECH
    • INNOVATIONS
    • TELCOM
  • OpED
  • EDUCATION
  • INVESTIGATION
    • NATIONAL ARCHIVE
    • SPECIAL REPORT
    • ANALYSIS
  • FEATURES
    • SOCIETY
    • Community
    • Pictorial
    • PROFILES
    • Lifestyle
    • Health
    • ENVIRONMENT
  • Tours & Travel
    • Hotel & Hospitality
  • Sports
  • About Us

© 2024 Ugstandard - Latest News by Digital/New Media company.

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
%d