Saturday, July 12, 2025
UG Standard - Latest News
  • Home
  • News
    • DIPLOMACY
    • COURT
    • AFRICA
    • BOOK REVIEW
    • INTERVIEW:
    • National
    • Parliament
    • World
    • Regional
  • Business
    • AGRIBUSINESS
    • OIL & GAS
    • REAL ESTATE
    • TECH
    • INNOVATIONS
    • TELCOM
  • OpED
  • EDUCATION
  • INVESTIGATION
    • NATIONAL ARCHIVE
    • SPECIAL REPORT
    • ANALYSIS
  • FEATURES
    • SOCIETY
    • Community
    • Pictorial
    • PROFILES
    • Lifestyle
    • Health
    • ENVIRONMENT
  • Tours & Travel
    • Hotel & Hospitality
  • Sports
  • About Us
  • Login
UG Standard - Latest News
ADVERTISEMENT

Computer Misuse Act: What the Constitutional Court Judgement means for those being sought or tried for offensive communication

by JAVIRA SSEBWAMI | PUBLIC EDITOR
10/01/2023
in News
Reading Time: 5 mins read
A A
0
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
Justice Kenneth Kakuru (PHOTO/Courtesy).

KAMPALA — Constitutional Court has annulled Section 25 of the controversial Computer Misuse Act of 201, describing it a vegue with no space in a free and a democratic society.

The unanimous court Judgement delivered Tuesday, January 2023 that human rights defenders, critics, lawyers and journalists into jubilation also means that the cases of those being tried for offensive communication collapse and also police cannot arrest or detain anyone on charges of offensive communication.

Related posts

Hon. Haruna Kasolo (seated middle) with other individuals who accompanied him at NRM offices in Kyadondo on Thursday.

Minister Kasolo nominated for NRM Vice Chairperson, Buganda Region

03/07/2025
217
The accused persons in court today.

Vandalism of Electricity Equipments: 17 charged with terrorism

02/07/2025
208

Looming unemployment: Farmers, Residents in shock as NEMA boss orders the demolition of multi million chicken farm

30/06/2025
343
Suspects in court on Monday.

Mpigi District boss, District Service Commission Members Charged over illegalities in Job offers

30/06/2025
169

The Ugandan government had continued curtailing press and online freedoms over the past years, resulting in increasing self-censorship among both online journalists and ordinary users.

The five justices of the Constitutional Court unanimously agreed that the law ought to be struck out in a free and democratic society because it curtails freedom of speech, does not specify what constitutes offensive communication, its vague and overly broad and ambiguous and it does not afford sufficient guidance for legal debate.

“I find that the impugned Section is unjustifiable as it curtails the freedom of speech in a free and democratic society. In conclusion, I would allow the petition with costs to the petitioners and make the following declarations and orders… that Section 25 of the Computer Misuse Act no.2 of 2011 is null and void as it’s inconsistent with the Constitution,” ruled Justice Kenneth Kakuru, who wrote the lead judgment, adding that:

“…In a democratic and free society, prosecuting people for the content of their communication is a violation of what falls within guarantees of freedom of expression in a democratic society. In the European Court of Human Rights case …it was observed that freedom of expression includes the right to say things that ‘offend, shock or disturb the peace of the state or any sector of the population’. The Court concluded that prosecution in such cases would not be appropriate,”

Justice Kakuru further agreed with the arguments of the duo petitioners, Mr Andrew Karamagi and Mr Robert Shaka that the said law was overly vague as it did not spell out what ingredients constitute the same offense.

Mr. Eron Kiiza, one of the lawyers who argued the petition, had submitted that the impugned Section created an offence and punishment without precisely defining key terms and phrases like “disturbing the peace, quiet and privacy of anyone” and “with no purpose of legitimate communication”.

He had further argued that the impugned law was disproportionate as it loops all protected speech without any clear boundaries and its criminalization of speech and communication was the intrusive method of restricting the right and freedom of speech and expression.

“Secondly Section 25 of the Computer Misuse Act No. 2 of 2022 does not specify what conduct constitutes offensive communication. To that extent it does not afford sufficient guidance for legal debate. Thirdly it is vague, overly broad and ambiguous,” Justice Kakuru held as he struck down the law.

The other justices who agreed with the lead decision of Justice Kakuru included; Deputy Chief Justice Richard Buteera, Geoffrey Kiryabwire, Elizabeth Musoke and Monica Mugenyi.

The annulled law, Section 25 of the Computer Misuse Act No, 2 of 2011; had stated that any person who “willfully and repeatedly” uses electronic communication to disturb or attempts to disturb the peace, quiet or right of privacy of any person with no purpose of legitimate communication whether or not a conversation ensues, commits a misdemeanor and is liable on conviction to a fine not exceeding twenty-four currency points (Shs500, 000) or imprisonment not exceeding one year or both.

In his analysis, Justice Kakuru held that a statute is void for vagueness if a legislature’s delegation of authority to judges and/or administrators is so extensive that it would lead to arbitrary prosecutions.

“I find that the words used under Section 25 are vague, overly broad and ambiguous. What constitutes an offence is ‘unpredictable’ and gives the law enforcer the discretion to pick and choose what qualifies as offensive. It gives the law enforcement unfettered discretion to punish unpopular or critical protected expression,” observed Justice Kakuru.

Adding: “…the limitation imposed by such a law must not be more than is reasonably necessary to achieve the legitimate objective. This is what is also known as the principle of proportionality. The principle requires that such a law must not be drafted too widely so as to net everyone including even the untargeted members of society,”

Mr Karamagi, a lawyer, had in his affidavit to support the petition filed in 2016, and argued that like scores of other citizens in Uganda, he was a regular user of the internet, especially social networking sites such as Facebook and Twitter.

He further argued that he found the said law to be in excessive restriction on his freedom of speech and expression since it provided the Director of Public Prosecution (DPP); unbridled administrative and prosecutorial discretion which had resulted in several cases of selective prosecution of Internet users based on certain views deemed objectionable by the government or high ranking politicians and public officers.

Mr Karamagi also told court that the enforcement of the said law had placed him under constant fear of violating it.

The decision of the court comes at the time when several human rights bodies and journalists’ bodies have petitioned the same court, challenging the recent enactment of Computer Misuse (Amendment) Act, 2022 as being a threat to freedom of speech.

Popularly known as the Nsereko law, the same law among others; penalises a person to a fine of more than Shs9m or imprisonment of more than 10 years if they are found culpable of accessing, without authorisation, another person’s information, data, voice or video records.

Further, the law penalises those who invade children’s privacy and share their information without consent of their parents or guardians.

The Constitutional Court and the East African Court of Justice were these petitions about four in number have since been filed, are yet to be determined.

Human Rights defender react to the judgement

Mr Robert Sempala, the Executive Director of the Human Rights Network for Journalists-Uganda described the ruling as one that has ‘justified our augments’.

said at least one bad law is off the law books.

“From the onset, we said this is an unprogressive legislation meant to clamp down on freedoms of speech and expression and court has ably justified our augments. We are very happy as advocates of freedom of speech, at least we are one bad law less to our progressive efforts for a free speech,” Mr Sempala said.

Likewise, lawyer Kiiza, said the annulled section of the law was the most notorious one and that this is a win to freedom of speech.

He further said the decision of the court is now a relief to government critics like Dr Stella Nyanzi and book writer Rukirabashaija Kakwenza, who have both, since fled the country after being charged with the same law of offensive communication.

“It is a sigh of relief for activists, government critics and human rights defenders who are either charged under or threatened by charges of offensive communication. It is bad news for the recently enacted Computer Misuse (Amendment) Act, 2022 which is an even more ambiguous, regressive and repressive legislation. The court will employ the same reasoning to annul it,” Mr Kiiza said by telephone.

Adding: “It is a win for freedom of expression. And we are saying bye to one of the most dangerous pieces of legislation that government has used to repress, stifle and ultimately lead to the exiling of Kakwenza Rukirabashaija and Stella Nyanzi; and used to silence others,”
Dr Nyanzi was jailed for 18 months after she was found guilty of insulting the late mother of President Museveni. The same sentence was later quashed on appeal to the High Court.

Similarly, Mr Kakwenza who was allegedly tortured at the hands of the State operatives before fleeing to Germany, is accused of insulting President Museveni and his son, Gen Muhoozi Kainerugaba on social media. His charges of offensive communication are still pending before Buganda Road Court in Kampala.

Share this:

  • Share
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Click to share on Telegram (Opens in new window) Telegram
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

Tags: Computer Misuse ActCourt nullifies Computer Misuse Act 2011FeaturedJustice Kenneth Kakuru

Related Posts

 Abbas urges U.S. to compel Israel to stop violations against Palestinians
News

 Abbas urges U.S. to compel Israel to stop violations against Palestinians

05/11/2022
0
307

Abbas urges U.S. to compel Israel to stop violations against Palestinians RAMALLAH, Nov. 4 (Xinhua) -- Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas...

Read moreDetails
Equity ranked 4th strongest banking brand globally on brand strength, scoring 92.4 points out of 100

 Equity Bank Under Scrutiny for Alleged Role in UGX.3bn Fake Gold Scam

09/07/2024
625
Minister of Health Dr. Ruth Aceng and Permanent Secretary Dr. Diana Atwiine pay their respects at the burial of Dr. Joshua Musinguzi, a champion in the fight against HIV/AIDS in Uganda. Their presence honors his legacy and dedication to improving healthcare in Uganda.

 FULL LIST: Health Service Commission Shortlists Applicants for Key Roles

18/06/2025
1.4k
Kabuleta and other opposition politicians have teamed up to put an end to Museveni's leadership

 Kabuleta, other opposition politicians team up to put an end to Museveni’s leadership

27/02/2024
503
Load More

Popular Articles

  • Check out the top schools with pupils who scored 6 in 4 aggregates in the 2024 PLE results, as released by UNEB

    PLE 2024 Results: Top Schools with 6 in 4 Aggregates

    4377 shares
    Share 1751 Tweet 1094
  • How to Renew Your National ID Online: NIRA Pre-Registration Portal 2025 Guide

    4059 shares
    Share 1624 Tweet 1015
  • NIRA unveils high-tech National ID, mass enrollment set to begin

    2667 shares
    Share 1067 Tweet 667
  • FULL LIST: Ministry of Education, NCDC publish self-study workbooks amid COVID-19 lockdown

    3323 shares
    Share 1348 Tweet 823
  • How to Check PLE Results 2024 on Phone, Online

    1785 shares
    Share 714 Tweet 446
  • PLE 2024 Results: UNEB Clarifies on Release Date

    1651 shares
    Share 660 Tweet 413
  • MPs clear govt to cancel 2020 academic year

    2796 shares
    Share 1150 Tweet 686

Recent Articles

The IGG Beti Kamya urged Ugandans to help expose suspicious wealth, such as high-rise apartments owned by public officials.

How the Office of the IGG is Turning the Tide in Uganda’s Fight Against Corruption

11/07/2025

betPawa Makes History with Africa’s Biggest Aviator Win — UGX 3,582,370,00 in One Round

11/07/2025
Herbert Achai

Transfers: Herbert Achayi Returns to KCCA FC

11/07/2025
The accused persons at Court on Friday.

Gomba District Commission Members, charged with extortion and Soliciting Bribes for Jobs

11/07/2025
Brian Mulondo (C) moderates the MTN MoMo Power to be More campaign Launch with MTN's Richard Yego (L) and Jemima Kariuki (R)

MTN MoMo Broadens Digital Offerings to Empower Individuals, Businesses

11/07/2025
Uganda is phasing out individual taxi operators, requiring drivers to join associations or SACCOs to streamline public transport. The government also announced digital penalties for traffic violations

Kampala Air Pollution Exceeds WHO Limits, Studies Show

11/07/2025
UCC Executive Director Nyombi Thembo, these illegal operations disrupt fair competition and create risks to lives, property, and trust

Telecoms sector facing increasing cybercrime

11/07/2025

Recent CommentsRecent Comments

  • The Journey of Ibrahim Traoré on How President Ibrahim Traoré’s ambitious vision is driving Burkina Faso’s economic growth push
  • Ugandan Scientists Finalists For European Inventors Prize — Press Uganda on Ugandan scientists finalists for European inventors prize
  • Government Pumps UGX1 Trillion Into UDB To Drive Industrialization, SME Growth — Press Uganda on Government pumps UGX1 Trillion into UDB to drive Industrialization, SME growth
  • PS Ggoobi Tips On Building USD 500b Economy — Press Uganda on PS Ggoobi tips on building USD 500b economy
  • Museveni Meets German Envoy Matthias Schauer After Subversion Claims — Press Uganda on Museveni meets German envoy Matthias Schauer after subversion claims

UG Standard - Latest News

UG Standard, published via www.ugstandard.com isa publication of Sahel Media Solutions Ltd, a professional Digital/New Media company in Uganda info@ugstandard.com

Follow us on social media:

Latest News

  • How the Office of the IGG is Turning the Tide in Uganda’s Fight Against Corruption
  • betPawa Makes History with Africa’s Biggest Aviator Win — UGX 3,582,370,00 in One Round
  • Transfers: Herbert Achayi Returns to KCCA FC
  • Gomba District Commission Members, charged with extortion and Soliciting Bribes for Jobs
  • MTN MoMo Broadens Digital Offerings to Empower Individuals, Businesses
  • Kampala Air Pollution Exceeds WHO Limits, Studies Show

OpED

Equipping Youth with Skills for a Sustainable Future: A Mission We Must All Embrace

Fueling the Future: How Pesapal’s Forecourt Management Solution is Transforming Uganda’s Petroleum Sector

HELLEN MASIKA: From Darkness to Solar Light in Kijumba 

Why de-register a Motor Vehicle in Uganda: and Consequences of Non-Compliance

Challenges of taxing law firms in Uganda

© 2024 Ugstandard - Latest News by Digital/New Media company.

Welcome Back!

Sign In with Facebook
OR

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • DIPLOMACY
    • COURT
    • AFRICA
    • BOOK REVIEW
    • INTERVIEW:
    • National
    • Parliament
    • World
    • Regional
  • Business
    • AGRIBUSINESS
    • OIL & GAS
    • REAL ESTATE
    • TECH
    • INNOVATIONS
    • TELCOM
  • OpED
  • EDUCATION
  • INVESTIGATION
    • NATIONAL ARCHIVE
    • SPECIAL REPORT
    • ANALYSIS
  • FEATURES
    • SOCIETY
    • Community
    • Pictorial
    • PROFILES
    • Lifestyle
    • Health
    • ENVIRONMENT
  • Tours & Travel
    • Hotel & Hospitality
  • Sports
  • About Us

© 2024 Ugstandard - Latest News by Digital/New Media company.

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
%d