Tuesday, July 1, 2025
UG Standard - Latest News
  • Home
  • News
    • DIPLOMACY
    • COURT
    • AFRICA
    • BOOK REVIEW
    • INTERVIEW:
    • National
    • Parliament
    • World
    • Regional
  • Business
    • AGRIBUSINESS
    • OIL & GAS
    • REAL ESTATE
    • TECH
    • INNOVATIONS
    • TELCOM
  • OpED
  • EDUCATION
  • INVESTIGATION
    • NATIONAL ARCHIVE
    • SPECIAL REPORT
    • ANALYSIS
  • FEATURES
    • SOCIETY
    • Community
    • Pictorial
    • PROFILES
    • Lifestyle
    • Health
    • ENVIRONMENT
  • Tours & Travel
    • Hotel & Hospitality
  • Sports
  • About Us
  • Login
UG Standard - Latest News
ADVERTISEMENT

FULL RULING: Court halts sale of Bitature properties

by Julian Ninsiima | Reporter
28/06/2022
in News
Reading Time: 5 mins read
A A
0
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
The Court of Appeal has blocked the sale of city businessman Patrick Bitature’s properties
The Court of Appeal has blocked the sale of city businessman Patrick Bitature’s properties

Businessman Patrick Bitature has been given temporary reprieve after the Court of Appeal issued an injunction blocking Vantage Mezzanine Fund, a South Africa-based lender, from selling his prime properties in Kampala to recover a loan.

Justice Christopher Gashirabake on Monday, June 27, 2022, ruled that the businessman through his lawyers of Muwema and Company Advocates has proved that his properties, among them Protea Hotel (Skyz’s Hotel) in Naguru, are facing a threat of sale.

Related posts

Minister , Gen David Muhoozi addressing the gathering at Golf Course Hotel on Thursday. (Courtesy photo)

Violence free elections is everyone’s responsibility – Minister Muhoozi

27/06/2025
166
Women Coffee farmers

Women Coffee Farmers Demand Recognition and Support

26/06/2025
157
Mwesigwa Rukutana (middle) with other lawyers representing the Balalo

Balalo petition High Court over looming eviction from Northern Uganda

25/06/2025
155
Jamil Mukulu at High Court a few years back.

ICD Upholds the trial of Jamil Mukulu and two others

24/06/2025
169

“There is all evidence that there is a real threat of sale/disposal of the property before determination of the main arguments of jurisdiction of this court can be determined. For this reason, I grant the protective order sought,” Justice Gashirabake ruled.

Mr Bitature, who is the chairperson of Simba Group of Companies, went to the appellate court after the Commercial Division of the High Court dismissed his application in which he had sought to stop the advertisement and auctioning of his properties.

Mr Bitature had sought a temporary injunction against lawyers Robert Kirunda, Wasige and bailiff Katerega from selling off their properties in a bid to recover the loan until the final disposal of the pending courts cases.

Vantage says it lent Mr Bitature and his various companies $10 million in 2014 of which he has “not paid back one cent” despite the loan term ending in 2019. The lenders say the loan to Mr Bitature’s companies has now ballooned to $32 million after accrued and compounded interest, and penalties, kicked in.

But the judge yesterday ruled that, “any further form of threat of sale or dealing in the advertised property is hereby stayed until the determination of the application of interim orders of stay.”

Justice Gashirabake question the lawyers’ decision to advertise the businessman’s properties if there wasn’t any threat or imminent danger to them.

“Why would the advert in the Daily Monitor have been placed in the newspapers? The advert has not been withdrawn. Is any prudent person supposed to ignore the advert? The answer is a resounding NO. Would anyone rely on the advert to buy the property? Yes,” he said.

The affected properties include; Elizabeth apartments in Kololo, Protea Hotel (Skyz’s Hotel) in Naguru, Moyo Close apartments and Kololo gardens in Kampala.

Vantage’s lawyers had argued that the intended advertisement was to cause the sale of the properties owned by Bitature to recover the money that Vantage is demanding.

But Mr Bitature’s lawyers claimed that Vantage was non-existent and yet by the lawyers and bailiff advertising the said properties, have not only occasioned severe damage to their names and business reputation but have also caused or continue to cause irreparable damage to them.

Justice Gashirabake yesterday said Mr Bitature’s “application is not meant to stop or interfere with the ongoing arbitration, which has to continue, but to protect the property of the subject of the arbitration until the arbitration is concluded.”

The ruling means that Vantage cannot advertise and sell Mr Bitature’s properties to recover the loan until the matter is concluded by arbitration.

================================================================

Here is the ful ruling:

THE REPUBLIC OF UGANDA

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF UGANDA AT KAMPALA

CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 538 OF 2022

ARISING OUT OF CIVIL APPLICATION No. 537 OF 2022

ARISING OUT OF CIVIL APPEAL NO 2022

ARISING OUT OF HCMA No. 671 OF 2022 AND HCCS NO. 0424 OF 2022

SIMBA PROPERTIES INVESTMENT CO. LTD APPLICANTS
SIMBA TELECOM LTD vs
ROBERT KIRUNDA & NOAH SHAMAH WASIGE trading as M/S KIRUNDA & WASIGE ADVOCATES RESPONDENTS
FESTUS KATEREGGA trading as Quick way Auctioneers & Court Bailiffs
COMMISSIONER LAND REGISTRATION
When Civil Application NO. 538 of 2022 came up for hearing, Mr. Fred Muwema, Friday Roberts Kagoro and C. K Nsubuga appeared for the applicants and Mr. S. Tendo Kabenge, Robert Kirunda and Kasabiti Diana appeared for the Respondents.

Mr. Fred Muwema applied for a Protective Order, stating that there is an imminent threat of sale of the applicant’s properties comprised in;

LRV 3895 Folio 4 Plot 3 Water Land Naguru Kampala,

0 LRV 3435 Folio 10 Water Land Plot 12 Naguru Kampala and

LRV 4294 Folio 20 Plot 12 Moyo close.

LRV 3903 Folio 13 Plot 32 Elizabeth Avenue Kololo

LRV 3891 Folio 18 Plot 1 Water Lane Naguru Kampala

LRV 3895 Folio 3 Plot 5 Water Lane Naguru Kampala

The properties were advertised for sale by the respondents as Agents of Vantage Mezzanine Fund Limited, Vantage Mezzanine Fund Il Partnership and Derek Alexander Il Director, Vantage Mezzanine Fund Il proprietary Limited.

Mr. S.T Kabenge and Mr. Robert Kirunda objected to the application on ground that no threat of sale of the property was impending as alleged by the applicants. That the sale which should have taken place on the 18th June 2022 never took place and no such sale is contemplated.

Further that the application was improperly before this Court as the parties were in arbitration and therefore this Court lacked jurisdiction as per Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act.

That the Mortgagees were not parties to the suit and their Agents (Robert

Kirunda and Noah Sharnmah Wasige Trading as Ms Kirunda & Wasige & Advocates), Festus Kateregga trading as Quick way Auctioneers and Court bailiffs) were not the right parties in this application.
Counsel for the applicants submitted that before the lapse of 30 days after the advertisement for sale, the property is still available for sale and therefore the threat is still there.

Counsel for the respondents vehemently refuted this submission.

Counsel for the applicants prayed that the protective order be given under the provisions of the Rules of this Court particularly Rule 2(2) of the Judicature (Court of Appeal) Rules) Directions, SI 13-10 to preserve the status quo.

After carefully listening to the submissions of both counsel, I am convinced that Rule 2(2) of the Judicature (Court of appeal Rules) Directions SI 13-10 empowers this Court to make orders of Court where it is evident that there is a threat or eminent danger, of the sale of the property.

There is a copy of the advert in Daily monitor of Wednesday, May 18, 2022, attached as annexure B to the application. If indeed as the counsel for the respondents submitted that there is no threat or imminent danger of sale of the property, why would the advert in the Daily monitor have been placed in the newspapers? The advert has not been withdrawn. Is a prudent person supposed to ignore the advert? The answer is a resounding No!!. Would anyone rely on the advert to offer to buy the property. Yes!!

I am alive to the provisions of S. 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act and submission that this Court has no jurisdiction in this case.

The application is not meant to stop or interfere with the ongoing arbitration, which has to continue, but to protect the property the subject of the arbitration until the arbitration is concluded.

Having addressed myself to the above as I have done, there is all evidence that there is a real threat of sale/ disposal of the property before determination of the main arguments of jurisdiction of this Court can be determined.

For this reason, I grant the Protective Order sought.

Any further form of threat of sale or dealing in the advertised property is hereby stayed until the determination of the application of interim order of stay.

I order accordingly. I give no order as to costs.

Dated at Kampala this…….day of…2022.

Gashirabake

Justice of Appeal

Share this:

  • Share
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Click to share on Telegram (Opens in new window) Telegram
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

Tags: Businessman Patrick BitatureFeaturedNaguru SkyzSudhir Ruparelia

Related Posts

 Abbas urges U.S. to compel Israel to stop violations against Palestinians
News

 Abbas urges U.S. to compel Israel to stop violations against Palestinians

05/11/2022
0
303

Abbas urges U.S. to compel Israel to stop violations against Palestinians RAMALLAH, Nov. 4 (Xinhua) -- Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas...

Read moreDetails
Equity ranked 4th strongest banking brand globally on brand strength, scoring 92.4 points out of 100

 Equity Bank Under Scrutiny for Alleged Role in UGX.3bn Fake Gold Scam

09/07/2024
613
Minister of Health Dr. Ruth Aceng and Permanent Secretary Dr. Diana Atwiine pay their respects at the burial of Dr. Joshua Musinguzi, a champion in the fight against HIV/AIDS in Uganda. Their presence honors his legacy and dedication to improving healthcare in Uganda.

 FULL LIST: Health Service Commission Shortlists Applicants for Key Roles

18/06/2025
966
Kabuleta and other opposition politicians have teamed up to put an end to Museveni's leadership

 Kabuleta, other opposition politicians team up to put an end to Museveni’s leadership

27/02/2024
494
Load More

Popular Articles

  • Check out the top schools with pupils who scored 6 in 4 aggregates in the 2024 PLE results, as released by UNEB

    PLE 2024 Results: Top Schools with 6 in 4 Aggregates

    4359 shares
    Share 1744 Tweet 1090
  • How to Renew Your National ID Online: NIRA Pre-Registration Portal 2025 Guide

    3894 shares
    Share 1558 Tweet 974
  • NIRA unveils high-tech National ID, mass enrollment set to begin

    2659 shares
    Share 1064 Tweet 665
  • FULL LIST: Ministry of Education, NCDC publish self-study workbooks amid COVID-19 lockdown

    3322 shares
    Share 1348 Tweet 823
  • How to Check PLE Results 2024 on Phone, Online

    1782 shares
    Share 713 Tweet 446
  • PLE 2024 Results: UNEB Clarifies on Release Date

    1650 shares
    Share 660 Tweet 413
  • MPs clear govt to cancel 2020 academic year

    2796 shares
    Share 1150 Tweet 686

Recent Articles

Looming unemployment: Farmers, Residents in shock as NEMA boss orders the demolition of multi million chicken farm

30/06/2025
According to UNBS, motor vehicles arriving in Uganda without Certificates of Roadworthiness shall be subject to a penalty of 15% CIF value and will also be subjected to destination inspection prior to issuance of Import Clearance Certificate.

Why de-register a Motor Vehicle in Uganda: and Consequences of Non-Compliance

30/06/2025

Challenges of taxing law firms in Uganda

30/06/2025
Xi Jinping, general secretary of the CPC Central Committee, waves to journalists at the Great Hall of the People in Beijing, Oct. 23, 2022. Chinese economy continues to remain in distress

Beijing’s Invisible Hand: How China is Quietly Revolutionising Global Conflict

30/06/2025
Gender Minister Betty Amongi elaborates on the GROW Project's success in boosting women entrepreneurs across Uganda, highlighting its impact on economic empowerment and business growth

Uganda’s GROW Project: Eligibility Opens Doors for Women Entrepreneurs to Funding, Services

30/06/2025
Suspects in court on Monday.

Mpigi District boss, District Service Commission Members Charged over illegalities in Job offers

30/06/2025

MAUREEN NAMOMA: Digitising Uganda’s Fuel & Hospitality Sectors: Why the Time is Now

30/06/2025

Recent CommentsRecent Comments

  • The Journey of Ibrahim Traoré on How President Ibrahim Traoré’s ambitious vision is driving Burkina Faso’s economic growth push
  • Ugandan Scientists Finalists For European Inventors Prize — Press Uganda on Ugandan scientists finalists for European inventors prize
  • Government Pumps UGX1 Trillion Into UDB To Drive Industrialization, SME Growth — Press Uganda on Government pumps UGX1 Trillion into UDB to drive Industrialization, SME growth
  • PS Ggoobi Tips On Building USD 500b Economy — Press Uganda on PS Ggoobi tips on building USD 500b economy
  • Museveni Meets German Envoy Matthias Schauer After Subversion Claims — Press Uganda on Museveni meets German envoy Matthias Schauer after subversion claims

UG Standard - Latest News

UG Standard, published via www.ugstandard.com isa publication of Sahel Media Solutions Ltd, a professional Digital/New Media company in Uganda info@ugstandard.com

Follow us on social media:

Latest News

  • Looming unemployment: Farmers, Residents in shock as NEMA boss orders the demolition of multi million chicken farm
  • Why de-register a Motor Vehicle in Uganda: and Consequences of Non-Compliance
  • Challenges of taxing law firms in Uganda
  • Beijing’s Invisible Hand: How China is Quietly Revolutionising Global Conflict
  • Uganda’s GROW Project: Eligibility Opens Doors for Women Entrepreneurs to Funding, Services
  • Mpigi District boss, District Service Commission Members Charged over illegalities in Job offers

OpED

Why de-register a Motor Vehicle in Uganda: and Consequences of Non-Compliance

Challenges of taxing law firms in Uganda

SHEILA ABOTH: Maternal healthcare must be everyone’s business because it takes a village

DARIUS NIWAHA KISHAHO: Securing Health After Retirement: Why a Post-Retirement Medical Cover is a Necessity, Not a Luxury

Open Letter to the Chief Justice: Your Silence on Corruption is Very Loud

© 2024 Ugstandard - Latest News by Digital/New Media company.

Welcome Back!

Sign In with Facebook
OR

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • DIPLOMACY
    • COURT
    • AFRICA
    • BOOK REVIEW
    • INTERVIEW:
    • National
    • Parliament
    • World
    • Regional
  • Business
    • AGRIBUSINESS
    • OIL & GAS
    • REAL ESTATE
    • TECH
    • INNOVATIONS
    • TELCOM
  • OpED
  • EDUCATION
  • INVESTIGATION
    • NATIONAL ARCHIVE
    • SPECIAL REPORT
    • ANALYSIS
  • FEATURES
    • SOCIETY
    • Community
    • Pictorial
    • PROFILES
    • Lifestyle
    • Health
    • ENVIRONMENT
  • Tours & Travel
    • Hotel & Hospitality
  • Sports
  • About Us

© 2024 Ugstandard - Latest News by Digital/New Media company.

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
%d